CUPE Ontario Seeks a Review of OMERS Performance (2023)

Christine Dobby of the Toronto StarreportsCUPE seeks a review of OMERS pension plan performance after a loss in 2020:

The union representing 125,000 Ontario municipal workers who are members of the OMERS pension plan is calling for a third-party review of the plan’s investment performance after it posted a “shocking” loss in 2020.

The Canadian Union of Public Employees Ontario published a report Wednesday that highlights what it says is a long-term pattern of underperformance by the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System, which manages the retirement income of more than 500,000 active and retired municipal employees.

The public call comes after OMERS published its annual results in February, revealing it had lost 2.7 per cent in 2020, a significant swing from the 6.9-per-cent gain it had set as a benchmark.

“We’d been warned that 2020 might be a bad year for returns, but we were shocked at how bad,” CUPE Ontario president Fred Hahn said during a virtual press conference Wednesday. He said the 2.7-per-cent loss amounted to about $3 billion. “No other comparable pension plans had a negative return in 2020.”

But OMERS said Wednesday “an additional third-party independent review is not warranted.”

George Cooke, chair of the board of directors of the OMERS Administration Corporation, said the pension plan is governed by an independent expert board that “continually and thoroughly reviews investment performance, independent of management, utilizing external experts where appropriate.”

“Following the 2020 results specifically, we undertook a thoughtful look at our investment strategy and past decisions with an open mind,” Cooke said in an emailed statement.

“We are confident in our strong new leadership team and have concluded that our current investment strategy is appropriate,” he said. (Blake Hutcheson took over as OMERS CEO last June and the pension plan named new heads of its capital markets and infrastructure businesses earlier this year.)

CUPE Ontario’s report notes that the Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan (HOOPP), the Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan and the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec posted annual returns for 2020 of 11.4 per cent, 8.6 per cent and 7.5 per cent, respectively.

The report also points to a longer-term trend of lower returns at OMERS, which had a 10-year annualized return of 8.2 per cent as of 2019. In contrast, HOOPP, Teachers and the Caisse had 10-year returns of 11.4 per cent, 9.8 per cent and 9 per cent, respectively, at that time. OMERS’ 2020 performance brought its long-term rate of return down even further.

PBI Actuarial Consultants Ltd. reviewed CUPE’s report, which is based on publicly available information. PBI said the comparisons made are reasonable and show “a significant gap in performance between OMERS and other comparable public pension plans and funds.”

“We hear a lot about front-line heroes these days and this is a critical pension plan for them,” Hahn said in an interview. “We need there to be a mechanism to discover what’s going on here and fix it.”

Many CUPE Ontario employees — which include special education assistants, Toronto Public Library employees and Children’s Aid Society workers — work part-time hours, earn low wages or both.

During the news conference, union leaders said their members are concerned about losing benefits such as pension payments that are indexed to inflation or being required to contribute more to make up for investing shortfalls.

Yolanda McClean, second vice-president of CUPE Ontario and a member of CUPE Local 4400, representing education workers at the Toronto District School Board, said workers in her local earn an average of $38,000 per year and are predominantly racialized women.

“We care about this plan. We want to fix whatever is going on at OMERS to turn the tide,” McClean said.

Hahn said CUPE leaders met with executives and board members from OMERS on two occasions this year. The union asked for a review of the pension plan’s investment returns, but Hahn said OMERS told them it wasn’t necessary.

OMERS, which has $105 billion in net assets, has pointed to three main factors for the 2020 loss. It said widespread lockdowns affecting the retail, transportation and entertainment sectors “significantly impacted” its real estate and private equity portfolio. With respect to publicly traded companies, OMERS said dividend-paying stocks it owns in the financial services and energy sectors were also hit hard.

Finally, the pension plan said it took steps amid the market turmoil of March and April 2020 to reduce foreign currency hedging positions, a move designed to protect against a potential decline in value of the Canadian dollar. It said those “prudential steps” achieved their objective but “resulted in currency losses, as the Canadian dollar appreciated after we reduced our hedges.”

David Milstead of the Globe and Mail alsoreportsthat CUPE report calls for third-party review, alleges underperformance by pension fund manager OMERS:

The union for Ontario public sector employees has renewed calls for an outside review of the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System, saying the pension’s 2020 loss is part of a long-term pattern of underperformance.

In response, OMERS said Wednesday that an independent review “is not warranted.”

The Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE) Ontario said that 2020 was “not just one tough year” for OMERS, which posted a negative 2.7-per-cent return in 2020. The union, which initially spoke out when OMERS released that result in February, issued a report Wednesday that suggests OMERS has underperformed its own internal benchmarks, as well as other large Canadian pension plans, for the past decade or more.

CUPE says OMERS’s 10-year return of 6.7 per cent is lower than seven other major Canadian pensions, whose returns over the period ranged from 8.5 per cent to 11.2 per cent. It’s also lower than the 10-year internal benchmark of 7.3 per cent. OMERS does not disclose the 10-year benchmark figure in its annual reports, which makes it different from the other plans, CUPE says. CUPE said OMERS provided the figure to the union.

The long-term underperformance can also be seen in the 10 years ended in 2019, indicating the issue is not solely the result of OMERS’s performance during the pandemic, according to CUPE.

CUPE has raised questions of OMERS management before, including a lengthy critique of its expenses after it announced its 2018 results. Fred Hahn, President of CUPE Ontario, said the union has engaged with OMERS management and “we kept being told everything would be fine ... we weren’t satisfied with that.”

Mr. Hahn and other CUPE members who appeared at a Wednesday press conference questioned whether benefits would ultimately be endangered.

(Video) Value of OMERS Defined Benefit Pension Plan

“We care about this plan – we want to fix whatever’s going on, to provide our members with certainty,” said Yolanda McClean of CUPE’s Toronto Education Worker/Local 4400.

In a statement, George Cooke, the chair of the board of directors of OMERS Administration Corp., said the board, which is nominated by the employer and employee sponsors of the plan, “continually and thoroughly reviews investment performance, independent of management, utilizing external experts where appropriate.”

“Following the 2020 results specifically, we undertook a thoughtful look at our investment strategy and past decisions with an open mind,” Mr. Cooke said in the statement. “We are confident in our strong new leadership team and have concluded that our current investment strategy is appropriate. An additional third-party independent review is not warranted.”

CUPE Ontario represents 125,000 of the pension’s 289,000 active members. Two CUPE researchers authored the report, which was reviewed by PBI Actuarial Consultants of Vancouver. “Overall, we believe the analysis is sufficient to conclude that OMERS investment performance in 2020 and longer term is significantly lower than other comparable plans,” wrote Bradley Hough of PBI.

In 2020, OMERS’s real estate investments posted an 11.4-per-cent loss, while the value of its private equity portfolio declined by 8.4 per cent. Its performance also suffered from being heavily invested in dividend-paying oil and gas and financial-services stocks and underweight in technology companies. The fund’s benchmark was a gain of 6.9 per cent, so it underperformed by 9.6 percentage points, the biggest margin of the past decade, according to CUPE.

Alright, let me begin by stating I hope everyone in Canada had a superb long weekend.

I was bombarded with emails last week bringing this CUPE Ontario issue to my attention but had to cover other material and wanted to take my time to cover this properly.

Let me just state that I personally find it very sad and disturbing when I see public-sector union representatives publicly go after the very pension that feeds them and their members.

Going after your pension in such a public manner is not only damaging the brand of your pension, it's also demoralizing for the people working hard at these pensions to make sure they remain fully solvent over the long run.

Moreover, as you will read below, Fred Hahn has a personal agenda going after OMERS, he has no clue of what he's talking about and quite frankly, I am not impressed with PBI Actuarial who should know better than comparing returns of pensions with different asset mixes and liabilities.They are comparing apples to oranges and missing a lot of important points.

First, CUPE Ontario put out apress releasestating “Not just ‘one tough year’”:

The long-term underperformance of the Ontario Municipal Employees Retirement System (OMERS) pension plan urgently requires a full and independent review, saysBucketsOntario in a report releasedtoday.

“Investment returns are a critical part of funding the pensions of front-line workers. Unlike the comparable eight large defined benefit pension plans and funds in Canada,OMERShas fallen short on that front,” said Fred Hahn, President ofBucketsOntario. “Not only were their 2020 returns shockingly below that of comparable pension plans, but we have seen, over time,OMERSregularly falling short of even their own, internal benchmarks.This is at least a decade-long problem. We need to find out whyOMERScontinues to post such poor investment returns. As the largest representative of workers in this plan, we want to ensure hard-working members’ pensions are protected and that they aren’t asked to pay forOMERS’mistakes.”

The report, titledNot Just One “Tough Year”: The Need for a Review ofOMERSInvestment Performance, examines howOMERSinvestments have performed compared to other large pension plans and funds. It also reveals howOMERShas underperformed compared to its own internal benchmarks.

OMERS’ claim that its 2020 return of -2.7%, or a loss of $3-billion, was due to the economic impacts ofCOVID-19 is unsupported in comparison to other major plans who were investing in the same economic climate and had healthy returns regardless. As well, thoughOMERShas publicly claimed its 2020 results were an anomaly and in no way indicative of its strength as a long-term investor, the report’s comparison ofOMERS’ 10-year returns with those of eight comparable plans, in periods both before and including 2020, shows those claims are simply notaccurate.

As the report details, over that much longer period of time,OMERS’ investment results still find it at the bottom of the pack for major Canadian pension plans and funds. Additionally,OMERS’ results have fallen short of its own internal benchmarks, and, unlike other major pension plans and funds,OMERSno longer reports this critical information in their annual reporting, making it difficult for plan members and their union representatives to hold their investment managersaccountable.

“This blatant issue of lack of transparency, which does not exist in other pension plans, makes it very difficult for sponsors likeBucketsOntario to understand whyOMERScontinues to underperform,” said Hahn. “We urgently need an independent and fully transparent review conducted by those of us, likeBucketsOntario and other sponsors from both sides of the table, who are the representatives of these hard-working plan members and employers. And we needOMERSto agree to fully co-operate in that independent and fully transparentreview.”

OfOMERS’ 289,000 active members,BucketsOntario is the largest sponsor, representing 125,000 planmembers.

“Retirement income security is critical for all workers, and we know that is best accomplished through defined benefit plans likeOMERS,” said Hahn. “Many of our members inOMERSare some of the lowest-waged workers in the plan and they have continued working for municipalities, school boards, and child welfare agencies in no small part because they can access a defined benefitpension.”

“Our concern does not lie with the defined benefit model but with the long-term investment return record atOMERS, which falls well short of what it could be and what is being achieved by other large plans and funds. As the largest plan sponsor, we appoint representatives to bothOMERSBoards, but restrictive confidentiality rules prevent these representatives from keeping us – and therefore our members – fully-informed about issues atOMERS, including these problematic investment returns. The first thing you need to do to solve a problem is to admit there is one and as this report details,OMERS’ investment issues are not new. It is well past time for plan sponsors to work together to fixOMERS.”

Take the time to download and read the CUPE Ontario reporthere.

To a layperson, this report is black and white, it clearly shows OMERS long-term performance (cherry-picking the data for maximum effect) has been lower than its peers and even lower than its benchmark portfolio.

But to an expert reading this report, it's so misguided, so biased, so warped, so grossly misleading that it took me minutes to read it and conclude this is a CUPE Ontario sanctioned "hit piece" which ignores important points and distorts facts in the most prejudicial way.

The first thing I can tell you is that the only measure of success for a pension plan -- whether it's OMERS, OTPP, OPTrust, HOOPP or CAAT pension plan -is it's funded status.

Hugh O'Reilly, the former chief executive officer of OPSEU Pension Trust (OPTrust) and Jim Keohane, the former CEO of Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan (HOOPP) wrote a wonderful comment about this five years ago which you can readhere.

Please note this part:

Positive investment returns are generally a good indication of success,but not always.There are scenarios in which investment returns have been positive and the funded ratio has declined, and conversely times when investment returns are negative yet the funded ratio improved.

Our own industry has been as guilty as anyone else in trumpeting annual returns. In a world in which so many people are in a pension rat race to accumulate the biggest pot of money before they retire, it feels normal to celebrate when we've been able to make our assets perform faster, higher and stronger.However, if we are honest with ourselves, it's not the business we're in. Does this mean that returns don't matter? Not at all. What it does mean is that as pension plans, our investment approach must be inextricably linked to the goal of keeping the plan fully funded.

(Video) Nobrega Says Omers Comfortable With Investment Strategy: Video

Growing and maintaining our funding surplus over time to ensure we can deliver pension benefits to our members leads to very different decision-making, particularly when it comes to risk management, and the nature and mix of assets that we hold in the investment portfolio.

For members, the true value of a defined-benefit (DB) pension plan is certainty at a stage of life when there is little runway to accumulate more. Beyond the dollars that will one day be paid, we give members the confidence that they can count on their pension to be there when they retire and that their contributions will remain as stable as possible during their working years.

When creating certainty is the true goal, taking undue risk with members' futures for the sake of a few hundred extra basis points in a given year makes no sense at all. That is why both of our organizations have adopted an approach that puts funding first, one in which we balance the need to generate returns with the need to effectively manage risk.

I'm happy to report that by this measure of success, all of Canada's large public pensions are doing very well as they are all fully funded.

Even after it experienced a 2.7% loss in 2020, OMERS isstill 97% funded:

At year-end, our funded status, calculated on a smoothed basis, remains at 97%,which is unchanged from last year. On a fair value basis (i.e., without smoothing), our funded ratio was 93% down from 101% in 2019. This decrease is driven by our negative investment return in 2020, discussed in the following Investments section.

We measured our funded status using a slightly lower real discount rate than last year, having decreased it by a further 5 bps to 3.85% (excluding inflation). Progressively lowering our discount rate in this manner is a key component of our strategy. Since 2015, we have reduced the real discount rate by 40 bps and we intend to keep lowering it, as a lower discount rate can help make the Plan more resilient to the funding risks we see on the horizon. We are doing this incrementally so that we balance our long-term financial health with benefit and contribution rate stability.

Pension Terminology

  • The“funded ratio”is the ratio of net investment assets to long-term pension obligations. It is an indicator of the long-term financial health of the Plan. It can be calculated on a “smoothed” or “fair value” basis:
    • "Smoothed”evens out the variations in annual returns over a five-year period.In this way, contribution rates and benefits are set using a more stable, long-term view of investment performance.
    • “Fair value”uses year-end values of OMERS assets, without any adjustments. Because our investment returns vary each year, this calculation results in a funded ratio that will also vary year over year. In some years the variation will be significant.
  • The“discount rate”is the interest rate used to estimate the dollar value of OMERS long-term pension obligations. It includes two components: a “real” rate before inflation and net of a margin for risk and an inflation estimate. Setting the discount rate is key to managing the Plan and addressing risk. Lowering it increases the dollar value of our pension obligations and therefore decreases our funded ratio but can help make the Plan more resilient against future adverse experience.

For all intensive purposes, 97% funded on a smoothed basis is fully funded.

And here's something else the CUPE Ontario report fails to mention.

Unlike other pensions plans, OMERS stillguarantees cost-of-living-adjustments(this will soon change).

In fact, OMERS and OPTrust are the only Canadian pensions still doing this, all the other major pension plans in Canada that manage assets and liabilities (HOOPP, OTPP and CAAT Pension Plan) adopted conditional inflation protection long ago, providing them with another critical lever to manage their funded status, something OMERS and OPTrust don't have access to.

However, effective January 1, 2023, OMERS will adoptshared risk indexing:

Provides the option for the SC Board, based on its annual assessment of the Plan’s health and viability, to reduce future inflation increases on benefits earned after December 31, 2022.

This change is effective January 1, 2023 and does not affect benefits earned before that date. This means that when you retire, the benefits earned on or before December 31, 2022 will be granted full indexation. Benefits earned on or after January 1, 2023 will be subject to Shared Risk Indexing, meaning that the level of indexation will depend on the SC Board’s annual assessment of the financial health of the Plan.

More information will be available closer to the implementation date.

Between you and me,it's about time that OMERS adopts shared risk indexingbecause it ensures inter-generational equity in risk sharing (as more members retire, they can afford to shoulder some of the risk of the plan),but there was pushbackfrom, you guessed it,Fred Hahn, president of CUPE Ontario.

Again, none of this is mentioned in this report from CUPE Ontario, it only mentions funded status quickly without getting into details and primarily focuses on performance without regard to differences in liabilities and asset mixes of these pensions.

The report also cherry-picks data to make OMERS look bad relative to its peers:

Again, these comparisons are absurd for a lot of reasons but the most important one is you are not comparing apples to apples, each pension has different liabilities, different asset mixes and quite truthfully, as I stated at the top,the only thing that ultimately counts is funded status.

For example, in terms of asset mix, OMERS has close half its assets in private markets, 28% divided equally in Real Estate and Private Equity and 20% in Infrastructure, and only 6% in Bonds:

By contrast, HOOPP has 50% of its assets in bonds, has successfully ridden bond yields down over the last 20 years but now that yields are at record lows, it's looking to beef up its infrastructure portfolio and other strategies in itsnew LDI 2.0 approach.

(Video) The heated debate between Fair Pensions For All, OMERS and CUPE (Part I)

Basically, as HOOPP grows, it's looking to shift its asset mix so that it looks more like that of its larger Canadian peers including OMERS.

And just so we are clear, I remember Jim Keohane, HOOPP's former CEO, telling me "OMERS has great infrastructure assets" precisely because it was one of the first to diversify into this asset class "when valuations were more reasonable" (Jim's words).

What else? That RBC Pension Plan Universe which they included in this report is heavily skewed to global public equities which is why it delivered 9.2% annualized last year, but over the long run, it hasn't produced better risk-adjusted returns than the large Canadian pensions which have more invested in private markets and have the right approach too.

Another thing, when OMERSreleased its resultsin late February,Blake Hutcheson, OMERS President and CEO, was spot on to draw attention to the long run:

“We are a long-term investor that pays pensions over decades, and with a strong team and strategy in place, this single year will not define us,” said Blake Hutcheson, OMERS President and CEO.

Over the ten-year period leading up to 2020, OMERS investment portfolio performed well by any measure, averaging an annual return of 8.2%, and in 2019 alone OMERS delivered 11.9%. We are active investors and asset managers with high-quality assets diversified globally and we believe in the strong investment future that our portfolio represents for over 500,000 members and our more than 1,000 employers in Ontario,” he added.

OMERS funded status on a smoothed basis remains at 97%, with a lower discount rate of 5.85%. “Over the past five years OMERS has lowered its discount rate by 40 basis points, to improve resilience to risks we see on the horizon,” said Jonathan Simmons, OMERS CFO.

We are making the appropriate changes to better position our platform for the future. Pension payments continue as usual and OMERS paid pension benefits of $5.1 billion in 2020 to more than 180,000 members.

“As announced early in January we are entering a new year with a refreshed senior team to shape our way forward,” said Mr. Hutcheson. “Collectively this new team brings deep experience from inside and outside of OMERS, multiple countries, perspectives and backgrounds, and it achieves much greater gender diversity. I would confidently put this new team up against any other to deliver on OMERS commitment to our members in the years ahead.”

The fundamentals of our strategy remain sound. In any year, regardless of result, we would evolve our approach to adapt to current realities. Given the disruptions we experienced this year, we have made a number of important adjustments that lend additional strength to our approach,” said Mr. Hutcheson.

So, going into 2020, the 10-year annualized return was 8.2%, which was in line with its peers (never mind what they say in the report). Also worth noting, the 3 and 5-year annualized returns going into 2020 were just as solid (8.5%).

Then the pandemic hit, OMERS lost 2.7% and it impacted its short and long-term results:

I note that OPTrust was not included in their report. It also fared well in 2020,delivering 8.9% last year, giving it a 10-year annualized return of 7.8% which is above that of OMERS's 6.7%.

Again, who cares? OMERS got hit in 2020 for reasons I discussed in detail on this bloghere.

The CUPE report discusses "lack of transparency" but there was plenty of transparency about where things didn't go well last year:

Also, Blake Hutcheson was very transparent with me as to where OMERS got hit in Real Estate and Private Equity:

Blake and I spoke about real estate. They got hit in Retail and Offices in Calgary and New York City.

Interestingly, Blake told me Retail represents 16% of the real estate book and diversification (both geographic and sectors) helped mitigate some of the fallout.

Still, the lockdowns impacted malls, hotels, offices, airports, toll roads, and two of their 20 private equity companies -- Cineplex and a recruiting agency -- both of which accounted for 90% of the losses in PE (-8.4%).

Blake admitted that they need more diversification in Private Equity and "smaller ticket sizes" but the damage was done, the global pandemic wreaked havoc on some private businesses.

Think about it, companies cannot function with a no revenue model, some of OMERS portfolio companies were severely impacted by the lockdowns, more than their peers which were also impacted.

Some of their tenants went belly up, that impacted their real estate revenues.

Also, the footnote in the press release is important:

* For disclosure purposes, we present our investments and our performance by asset class. As such, Oxford Properties’ real estate credit business and public equity investment into HKSE-listed ESR Logistics is presented under ‘credit’ and ‘public equity’ respectively, and not in ‘real estate’.Including the performance of its credit business and investment in ESR Logistics, the Oxford Properties 2020 net return is -6.8%.

Blake told me Oxford lost 7% last year but because REITs are shifted to capital markets, the real losses in Real Estate were not as bad as reported (-11.4%).

It's important to note that most of Canada's large pensions lost money in Real Estate last year, including CPP Investments which justposted a 20% return(it lost 4% in Real Estate).

Why? In short, they got slammed in Retail and Offices but made money in logistics, healthcare, and multifamily properties. Also, those that were more exposed to Canadian properties got hit harder.

But pandemics don't occur every year, they occur once in a lifetime (hopefully) and we really need to put 2020 behind us once and for all.

As I stated when I covered OMERS 2020 results, there's no doubt in my mind that OMERS will bounce back this year, and that's what is going on.

(Video) Loyalist Township Council Meeting - Nov 22, 2021

Last week, I covered how AIMCo and OMERSsold ERM to KKR.

The sale of ERM is OMERS Private Equity’s fourth realisation in Europe and its fifth successful exit globally in the past three years.

That tells me they are printing money this year in private markets, and even in public markets where the tech melt-up of last year has cooled significantly and value stocks are more in favor, things are reverting back to the mean.

I suspect by this time next year, this chart will need to be updated:

Don't hold your breadth, however, I doubt Fred Hahn and CUPE Ontario will update their results if they look remotely favorable to OMERS.

Mr. Hahn obviously has an axe to grind, he's running to be re-elected and he found his whipping boy, the very pension that feeds him and his members.

But in publicly going after OMERS, he's only weakening the organization's brand and to be really honest, he's exposing how clueless he is about what really matters.

There's nothing nefarious going on at OMERS. Period.You don't need a third-party independent review, you need to trust the organization's independent governance and let OMERS senior managers execute on their long-term strategy.

Last year wasn't a disastrous year. Trust me, I've seen a few disastrous years covering pensions over a decade, this wasn't one of them.

It was a bad year, one OMERS has already put behind it.

I suggest Fred Hahn and other CUPE Ontario members do the same,focus on the long run, OMERS has great assets, assets other pensions can only dream of owning (like Bruce Power).

When I read the conclusion of the report, I was floored:

Serious concerns with OMERS investment performance? Really? I have no concerns, none, zero, zilch!

My concerns are with power hungry union hacks who think they're pension experts even though they clearly don't have the fainstest of what they're talking about.

And I'll leave it at that before my Greek side comes out and I eat Fred Hahn for dinner (it's time for dinner and I get very irritable when I'm hungry).

Read thereportthey put together with a shaker of salt, it's grossly biased, grossly misleading and quite frankly, it misses the most critical point, namely, OMERS is fully funded and doing great.

More discouragingly, it's totally disrespectful to the hard-working men and women at OMERS and it's demoralizing reading these articles by reporters who also don't have a clue about pensions.

For example, David Milstead of the Globe and Mail wrote anarticle last weekon how CPP Investments made 20% in fiscal 2021 but underperformed its benchmark.

Really buddy? Who cares if it underperformed its benchmark? They made 20% and the Fund's long-term return is way above the required minimum rate of return for the CPP to be solvent over the next 75 years set by the Chief Actuary of Canada. That's all Canadians care about.

It drives me nuts reading these articles, it's as if reporters are looking for anything negative because that's what sells newspapers.

Anyway, bottom line, forget Fred Hahn and CUPE Ontario's "hit piece" on OMERS. It has more holes in it than Swiss cheese and anyone in the pension industry with half a brain will ignore it.

Below, onApril 6, OMERS hosted its 2021 Annual Meeting. Over 1,300 people registered for this virtual event to hear from the OMERS Executive Leadership Team on a variety of topics.

I actually couldn't embed it below because it's not on Vimeo or YouTube (it should be) but a full recording of the webcast is availablehere.

Take the time to watch this, especially listen to Blake Hutcheson's comments starting at the45 minute mark. He explains a lot and is more than transparent!

Again, my only criticism is that OMERS doesn't have a dedicated YouTube channel to post these webcasts there so I can easily embed them here. Take the time to watch ithere.


Is OMERS a good investment? ›

OMERS remains highly rated by four credit rating agencies, including two 'AAA' ratings.

How much is the Ontario Teachers pension plan worth? ›

2022 Highlights:

Value added beyond benchmark of $4.4 billion. The plan is fully funded for a 10th straight year.

What is the rate of return on the OMERS pension plan? ›

Pension fund manager OMERS earned 4.2% return for 2022 | Investment Executive.

Is OMERS pension guaranteed? ›

As a defined benefit pension plan, OMERS provides a guaranteed stream of retirement income for life, based on your earnings and years of service.

Is the OMERS in trouble? ›

Highs and lows. In 2020, OMERS reported a net investment loss of $3 billion. One year earlier, it had net investment income of $11.4 billion and by 2021, it was back in the black, with a return of $16.6 billion.

What are the results of OMERS 2023? ›

For example, the increase as of January 1, 2023 is 6.00%. If your pension started in February 2022, your 2023 increase would be 5.00% (which is 0.8333 of 6.00%). In January 2024, your pension will receive the applicable 2024 increase.

What is the average retired teacher pension in Ontario? ›

When paired with income from the Canada Pension Plan and Old Age Security, an Ontario Teachers' pension may generally provide enough money for a comfortable retirement. The average teacher now retires at the age of 58, with an annual pension of around $46,000 (according to OTPP).

What is the increase for Ontario Teachers pension plan for 2023? ›

In 2023, all pensions will receive the full 6.3% increase. The adjustment takes effect in January 2023. The adjustment is based on 100% of the adjustment in the Consumer Price Index (CPI), a weighted basket of goods and services typically purchased by Canadian households each month.

Is Ontario Teachers pension for Life? ›

The plan provides a lifetime pension to Ontario's active and retired teachers, and their survivors. It also provides benefits if members die, become disabled or permanently leave teaching before retirement.

What is the best pension plan in Ontario? ›

The best kinds of pension plans in Canada are the Defined Contribution Pension Plan (DCPP), Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), Canada Pension Plan (CPP), Old Age Security (OAS), and Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS).

How is OMERS doing? ›

With a world-class team of investors and professionals across offices in North America, Europe, Asia and Australia, OMERS has generated $124.2 billion in net assets, as at December 31, 2022, making it one of the largest defined benefit pension plans in Canada.

What is the average pension for retirees? ›

Average Monthly Retirement Income

According to data from the BLS, average incomes in 2021 after taxes were as follows for older households: 65-74 years: $59,872 per year or $4,989 per month. 75 and older: $43,217 per year or $3,601 per month.

Do pensions ever run out? ›

Pension payments are made for the rest of your life, no matter how long you live, and can possibly continue after death with your spouse.

Does a pension ever run out of money? ›

Do Pensions Pay You Forever? Pensions typically pay benefits for the lifetime of the retiree. However, in some cases, pension payments may continue to be made to the spouse of a deceased retiree. If you choose a lump sum payment option, you will receive all of your benefits in one lump sum payment.

Can you lose your retirement pension? ›

Once a pension has vested, you should be entitled to keep those funds, even if you're fired. However, you aren't always entitled to all the money in your pension fund. In some cases, you might lose some, or even all, of your pension.

Why are pensions failing? ›

Pension plans can become underfunded due to mismanagement, poor investment returns, employer bankruptcy, and other factors. Religious organizations may opt out of pension insurance, giving their employees less of a safety net.

How do I get out of OMERS? ›

Your Options When Leaving
  1. Keep your pension in the OMERS Plan until you retire. ...
  2. Combine your current and future OMERS pension. ...
  3. Begin to receive your OMERS pension. ...
  4. Transfer your OMERS benefit to another registered pension plan. ...
  5. Transfer the commuted value (CV) of your pension.

Did OMERS lose money? ›

The pension fund, known as OMERS, lost 2.7 per cent on its investments last year, pushing assets to $105 billion (US$84 billion). It's the worst result since 2008, when it lost 15.3 per cent.

Will pension lump sums go down in 2023? ›

Since the lump sum equivalent of a monthly pension moves inversely to interest rates, this year's historic run-up can reduce lump sum cash-outs by 30% or more—larger reductions for younger payees, with smaller reductions for older payees. And for many, this change will arrive suddenly and possibly unexpectedly.

How much will retirement go up in 2023? ›

Social Security benefits and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) payments will increase by 8.7% in 2023. This is the annual cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) required by law.

What is the COLA increase for pensions in 2023? ›

Effective July 1, 2023, the COLA rate is 2.90% for those with a retirement date on or before July 1, 2022.

What age do most teachers retire Canada? ›

Learn how your age at retirement affects your pension.

The age at which you apply for your pension will affect the amount of your lifetime monthly pension payment. The normal retirement age for members of BC's Teachers' Pension Plan is 65 and the earliest retirement age is 55.

What is the maximum teacher pension in Ontario? ›

Your contribution to the Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan in 2023 is 10.4% of your salary up to the YMPE limit set by CPP ($66,600 in 2023). For any part of your salary above the YMPE limit, your contribution to the Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan is 12% of your salary.

Can I retire at 55 with teachers pension? ›

You can retire at age 55 with at least five years of service credit. Members under CalSTRS 2% at 60 also have the option to retire at age 50 with at least 30 years of service credit.

What is the cola for teachers in Ontario 2023? ›

Cost-of-living adjustment history
YearIncrease (%)
17 more rows

How many days can a retired teacher work in ontario 2023? ›

50-day limit extended to 95 days for some re-employment

Your pension will be suspended if even one of these conditions isn't met, or if you exceed the 50-day limit by the end of June 2023 and continue working in July or August.

Are Ontario teachers pensions indexed to inflation? ›

Pension credits earned in 2009 will continue to be 100 percent indexed; that is, benefits will be increased according to the increase in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). For service earned after 2009, 50 percent of the cost of living increase is guaranteed.

What age do most teachers retire? ›

This means that someone who enters teaching before age 25 with a bachelor's and accumulates 30 or more years of service can usually retire sometime between age 55 and 60. In most states teachers are eligible for retirement without penalty once they turn 60 even with less than 30 years of service.

When a teacher dies what happens to their pension? ›

If your beneficiary is an organization, any remaining monthly pension payments will be paid to the organization as a lump sum. Your spouse and dependent children may be eligible for extended health care and dental coverage through the plan after your death. Certain conditions apply, and coverage is not guaranteed.

Can you collect a pension and still work full time in Canada? ›

You can still work if you are receiving a CPP retirement pension, without reducing the pension amount. In fact, you could increase it by means of the CPP post-retirement benefit.

How much is the average pension in Ontario monthly? ›

Canada Pension Plan: Pensions and benefits monthly amounts
Type of pension or benefitAverage amount for new beneficiaries (January 2023)
Retirement pension (at age 65)$811.21
Post-retirement benefit (at age 65)$5.48
Disability benefit$1,132.55
Post-retirement disability benefit$558.74
8 more rows
Mar 31, 2023

What are the top 5 pension plans in Canada? ›

Best Retirement Plan Options in Canada
  • Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) ...
  • Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) ...
  • The Canada Pension Plan (CPP) ...
  • Old Age Security (OAS) ...
  • Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) ...
  • Employer-sponsored Pension Plans. ...
  • Other Investments. ...
  • Robo Advisors.
Feb 16, 2023

What is the average pension in Ontario Canada? ›

For 2022, the maximum starting pension for a new retiree at age 65 is $1,253.59/month. The average amount paid out to new retirees at 65, however, is $702.77/month. You can find out how much you're on track to receive from CPP using the Canadian Retirement Income Calculator provided by Service Canada Centres.

Who owns OMERS? ›

Trade nameOMERS
Number of employeesestimated 1000
ParentOMERS Administration Corporation Board of Directors
DivisionsOMERS Infrastructure OMERS Capital Markets OMERS Private Equity Oxford Properties
10 more rows

Does OMERS have an 80 factor? ›

The 80 Factor is available to members with a normal retirement age of 60 in the Primary Plan. A member has an 80 Factor when their age plus service ( credited service plus eligible service ) equals at least 80.

How to retire early with OMERS? ›

OMERS retirement and early retirement options

Or, you may retire as early as age 50 (for normal retirement age 60) or age 55 (for normal retirement 65). An early retirement pension can be either unreduced (no penalty) or reduced (with a penalty).

Is $4000 a month enough to retire on? ›

First, let's look at some statistics to establish a baseline for what a solid retirement looks like: Average monthly retirement income in 2021 for retirees 65 and older was about $4,000 a month, or $48,000 a year; this is a slight decrease from 2020, when it was about $49,000.

Is $6,000 a month good for retirement? ›

Median retirement income for seniors is around $24,000; however, average income can be much higher. On average, seniors earn between $2000 and $6000 per month. Older retirees tend to earn less than younger retirees. It's recommended that you save enough to replace 70% of your pre-retirement monthly income.

How much is a $30000 pension worth? ›

As an example, examine how much an earned pension income of $30,000 would add to a person's net worth. A defined benefit plan income of $30,000 annually is $2,500 per month, which is 25 times $100.

What are the results of the OMERS investment? ›

Over the twelve months ended June 30, 2022, the Plan earned a net investment return of 6.0%, or a gain of $6.7 billion, after reporting a net investment return of 15.7% or $16.4 billion for the 2021 calendar year.

What is the rating for OMERS Realty Corporation? ›

The rating takes into consideration ORC's stand-alone risk profile and its low level of secured debt as well as DBRS's view of the implicit support provided by OMERS Administration Corporation (OMERS; rated AAA with a Stable trend by DBRS).

What is the return of OMERS infrastructure? ›

Our real estate assets earned a 15.9% return and our real estate business, Oxford Properties, continued to expand its global footprint. Our infrastructure investments continued to deliver positive and consistent returns, earning 10.7% in 2021, underscoring our long-term strength in this asset class.

How did OMERS lose $3 billion? ›

The lion's share of that loss came from two holdings, Hutcheson said -- a movie theater chain and a recruiting company in Europe. Together, they constituted about 90 per cent of the drop.

Can you cash out OMERS? ›

You may take a cash refund of the commuted value of your benefit if the annual pension you have earned is less than 4% of $66,600*. This is often referred to as a “small pension”. You may also make a tax-deferred transfer of the cash refund to your RRSP.

What is the average pension investment growth? ›

"Over the long-term, investing offers the best chance of real, inflation-beating returns" Over the past 40 years, pensions have seen an average return of 7%.

How many members does OMERS have? ›


A jointly sponsored, defined benefit pension plan, with 1,000 participating employers ranging from large cities to local agencies and over half a million active, deferred and retired members.

What type of company is OMERS? ›

Founded in 1962, OMERS is one of Canada's largest defined benefit pension plans, with C$124.2 billion in net assets (as at December 31, 2022).

What is OMERS pension invested in? ›

Our Investment Portfolio

We are proud of our diversified portfolio of investments spanning Capital Markets, Infrastructure, Private Equity, Growth Equity, Ventures and Real Estate.

What drives 90% of a pension fund's return? ›

In summary, our analysis shows that asset allocation explains about 90 percent of the variability of a fund's returns over time but explains only about 40 percent of the variation of returns among funds.

What is the average pension plan returns? ›

The average assumed rate of return for public pension funds dropped in 2022 to 6.86% from 7.07% a year earlier, according to a report from the National Conference on Public Employee Retirement Systems.

What is the expected return for pension funds? ›

The expected investment return for a pension plan's assets is used as the discount rate for public and multiemployer pension plan valuations and is sometimes referred to as the “actuarial” rate of return.


1. General Government and Licensing Committee - June 29, 2021
(Toronto City Council)
2. General Government and Licensing Committee - January 6, 2020
(Toronto City Council)
3. November 8, 2021 - Regular Meeting of Council
(Central Elgin)
4. Council Meeting - November 15, 2021
(Brighton Ontario)
5. General Government and Licensing Committee - June 24, 2019 - Part 1 of 2
(Toronto City Council)
6. Webinar: Evolving the Pension Plan Member's Experience
(Common Wealth Retirement)


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lidia Grady

Last Updated: 09/09/2023

Views: 5435

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (65 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lidia Grady

Birthday: 1992-01-22

Address: Suite 493 356 Dale Fall, New Wanda, RI 52485

Phone: +29914464387516

Job: Customer Engineer

Hobby: Cryptography, Writing, Dowsing, Stand-up comedy, Calligraphy, Web surfing, Ghost hunting

Introduction: My name is Lidia Grady, I am a thankful, fine, glamorous, lucky, lively, pleasant, shiny person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.